CarMax Earnings Miss Sparks Price Target Re-Evaluation
about 1 month ago
Scarlett Foo & Paul Sweetin (discussion)
"Worst performer in the S&P 500 this morning by a large margin is CarMax, ticker KMX. ... Scott Siccarelli, maybe re-evaluate that price target of $74 because the stock is below $44."
CarMax reported an earnings miss and was marked as the worst performer in the S&P 500, trading near its lowest level since March 2020. Analysts are questioning the existing price target of $74 given that the stock is trading below $44. The sentiment is notably negative as the earnings disappointment and broader used car segment issues cast doubt on near-term performance.
Scores
Alpha Potential
8.0/10
Novelty
7.0/10
Credibility
7.0/10
Timeliness
7.0/10
Overall
7.4/10
Sentiment
Bearish
Conviction
High
Tier
Company Commentary
Related Stocks
Episode Information
Episode:
Eli Lilly Drops, CarMax Falls, Jabil Slides After Earnings
Source:Stock Movers
Published:
September 25, 2025
Idea Type:
Company Opinion